JohnDoe - I love the analagy with Tacos!!! That is very true!
.
Leave the kids alone, they did a class project!! Good for them!

I agree with gazettefan.

And we don't need a bunch of bloated glory-hounds trying to intimidate teachers and students in our schools.

I found out today that I know the STUDENT who suggested this to the Spanish class' teacher. The fact that a student had the initiative to try to enlighten the rest of the school to a different culture other than small town America by reciting THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE to AMERICA (not Mexico, Spain, or Cuba, but AMERICA)shows not only that kids today are trying to think outside of the box, demonstrate thinking GLOBALLY, yet pledging their allegiance to the country that gives them those rights is not only admirable but is a blessing to the Edgerton community and Wisconsin! Try to be like the high schoolers and think outside of the box, for the good of "these United States".

I still think your analogy is a bit melodramatic.

Yes, JohnDoe, there is more to that statement. Here is the entire post just as it appeared when you first saw the statement in question:

------------------

How is saying the Pledge in this instance disrespectful toward those who died fighting for our country? None of what has been said by those who opposed what the Spanish class did serves as an explanation.

What we have here are a few glory-hounds who exploited their veteran status for the sole purpose of bullying other people. They did this by behaving in a manner that would make any hardline communist or virolent fascist proud.

These veterans celebrated communism and fascism by stepping over the dead bodies of those Americans who died fighting against communism and fascism. Shame on them! They are a disgrace!

etown....that's like saying if the cafeteria offered tacos for lunch, it's forcing the students to change their culinary heritage.
Ridiculous.

johndoe , the focus isnt spanish class, the focus is saying the pledge on the intercom, during non class time activities, which in a way is forcing other student s to learn spanish even if they never signed up for the class, how else would they understand whats being said, my point was its not just this situation, this may be one point where someone felt the need to voice their opinion on what they did, right or wrong, what we need is someone to step up and say this is the usa , our children are taught in english, if you want your child to be educated here you need to teach them english

etown...mom24 is RIGHT.
The situation you mention may also be true, but the focus of this article is Spanish class. One of many foreign languages offered at the high school level across the country for years.
It has NOTHING to do with immigrants...legal or illegal.

mom24 , you are wrong , they are to asking our kids to learn spanish, there are kids enrolled in this district that dont speak english, and make no effort at trying, instead they get tutors, extra help, and in some classes they are using class time , ENGLISH CLASS TIME , to teach the other kids in the classroom spanish so they can communicate with one child, my problem with this whole situation, what about the other 25 students that are missing part of their english class , what happens next year when they are placed in different class rooms and are now behind, with the schools budget getting tighter and tighter should we be expected to fund the extra help these kids need , what about their parents responsibility , im not against anyone getting an education , but what about the other kids, they also have a right to the same education ,i highly doubt i could take my kids to another country and they would cater to them , they would be expected to learn their language ,

"These veterans celebrated communism and fascism by stepping over the dead bodies of those Americans who died fighting against communism and fascism. Shame on them! They are a disgrace!"
.
Please tell me there is more to this statement than the emotional diatribe that it appears to be.
.
If not, then you owe an apology to some veterans who's opinion does not match yours'.
.

Not saying I agree with their opinion(s), but that statement isn't warranted.

Of course they speak Mexican in Mexico, just like they speak Canadian in Canada.

MEXICAN LANGUAGE??????? Are you kidding?????
I hope you were JOKING. I haven't laughed so hard in a long time!!! Mexican language.......

In regards to Edgerton High saying the Pledge of Allegiance in spanish. There is a HUGE difference between the spanish language and the mexican language. Although both are based in latin and have some similarities, they are different. Spanish = Spain (in Europe) Mexican = Mexico (Central America)
Nobody would say one thing about the pledge being said in German, French or any other language class taught in high school. Stop being so ignorant and open your mind people!

Would you rather have people pledging allegiance in a foreign language, or pledging their hatred? I thought veterans died for freedom and liberty, not the English language.
_
We should say the pledge as it was originally intended - with no reference to God. Say it out loud including and excluding "God." It flows much better without God, and it's more inclusive. Did you know it was written by a Socialist! (at least according to this source:http://history.vineyard.net/pledge.htm)
_
For an interesting history of Francis Bellamy you might check out this source (http://history.vineyard.net/pdgech4.htm) which includes the Pledge author's views on Mexican labor (about 2/3 of the way down in the section "Editor of the Illustrated American").

If what matters is the language it was written in and not the words themselves, then some of you had better learn Hebrew and Greek so you can respectfully read those Bibles you're thumping.

How is saying the Pledge in this instance disrespectful toward those who died fighting for our country? None of what has been said by those who opposed what the Spanish class did serves as an explanation.

What we have here are a few glory-hounds who exploited their veteran status for the sole purpose of bullying other people. They did this by behaving in a manner that would make any hardline communist or virolent fascist proud.

These veterans celebrated communism and fascism by stepping over the dead bodies of those Americans who died fighting against communism and fascism. Shame on them! They are a disgrace!

gazettefan,
I looked the Spanish words this past weekend for the Pledge of Allegiance. Even with my limited knowledge of Spanish, It looked pretty much the same wording as in English. It didn't look subversive, and even included the phrase "under God" in it!
Thanks for posting that, g-fan.

2manykids-
Are you a veteran? I am, so please don't lump "all other veterans" together. I served in the Army for the freedoms we have as Americans, including the right to free speech. I don't see a Spanish class in high school saying the Pledge of Allegiance in Spanish as part of their learning as doing harm in any way to America.
Is it just that kids are learning Spanish, or would this be even a problem if they had done it in German or French?
As we are moving increasingly into global markets, I think it would be beneficial to learn another language, so that our children can catch up to the rest of the world, where many people know 2 or more languages fluently.
If we maintain the notion that Americans should only speak English, we are putting America at a disadvantage in world business and economy.
When I went to college, it was required we learn another language, such as Latin or German (Latin because of medical field's use of Latin terminology, or German, because a lot of scientific journals were printed in German). It's not required anymore, but anyone who can speak and read another language is definitely at an advantage in today's world markets.
Oh, this is funny! At the bottom of the page on this site is an ad to "Find the best Spanish Language Schools, in your area"!

If you say it and mean what you say, which I am sure they did, what is the difference what language it is in?

Juro fidelidad a la bandera
de los Estados Unidos de América,
y a la república que representa
una nación bajo Dios,
indivisible cón libertad
y justicía para todós.

I am very glad the students learned Spanish-I too know some.(I was only quoting the 500 million from DanHartung.) I just believe in what Myron Cobb said and that all other veterans deserve the respect that they have fought for --the Pledge of Allegiance should be said in English. Maybe they should have shown their skill by doing a Spanish play or song-but leave the Pledge of Allegiance in English.

The US doesn't even have 500 million people, try 304 million. This is "Spanish Class" not immigrant assimilation class. There may not even be a student of Latin American decent in the class. The students were just showing what they had learned.

I am not racist. I believe if you are in the US you should speak English--a second and third language is great to know,but we should not have to all learn it to understand each other.It's like flying the flag-the US flag comes on top-any other flag can be displayed below it. I believe the US deserves more respect. At the Olympics are not all the countries anthems sung in their own language?
The US does have 500 million Spanish speaking people-and English is becoming the second language.

2manykids sounds very racist and hateful. Is that what you are showing your kids? I hope not. We don't need any more racists in the world.

This has NOTHING to do with immigrants.
It was a class for Spanish as a second (or third) language.
It's time to stop reading into this something that is not there.

Hey Dan, part of immigration is a concept called assimilation. Good luck starting that business when you walk into a bank seeking a loan and you can't even read the application form, much less hold a meaningfull loan interview with the lending officer. Good Job Edgerton, way to go in doing your part of helping immigrants assimilate. Wonder if they are all legals by the way........

Congratulations to the Edgerton School Board, voting for education over ignorance and xenophobia. This is the 21st century and Spanish has 500 million speakers. This will help students get jobs and start businesses.

2manykids - oh really? Where did your ancestors come from? Mine came from Germany and that first generation really didn't learn much English. Their children (my grandparents) did when they went to school. The newspaper here in Fort Atkinson was actually published in BOTH English and German for a few years, English on one side of the page, German on the other.

For MOST immigrants throughout the history of this country, the first to arrive may barely learn the language. It is their offspring that begin the assimilation. Relax, it will happen with this wave of immigrants too.

No one is asking anybody to learn Spanish. This was all about a class of students who were proud of learning something new. What message are we sending todays youth? Racism? Intolerance? Sounds like a mountain made out of a mole hill. Oh, and people, you're making the kids involved feel like crap. So what are you?

Enough already-if I wanted to speak (or listen to )spanish I would live in Mexico. Our ancestors all were required to learn to speak English when they came here why can't the mostly illegal aliens learn it too instead of wasting our tax dollars paying for extra teachers to speak "their" language, free medical care, and don't forget the wonderful free housing. PLEASE enough already.
Remember Mexico requires you to speak Spanish when you work and live there. Why doesn't the US?

Wait a minute, they made a compromise? I don't understand why the pledge has to be said in both languages. Wasn't this a class project, and not a daily occurance?